Difference between revisions of "Game State Overviews"

From gdp3
Jump to: navigation, search
(Using the pattern)
 
(38 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
 
[[Category:Mechanical Patterns]]
 
[[Category:Mechanical Patterns]]
 
[[Category:Interface Patterns]]
 
[[Category:Interface Patterns]]
[[Category:Needs work]]
 
 
[[Category:Needs revision]]
 
[[Category:Needs revision]]
 
[[Category:Needs examples]]
 
[[Category:Needs examples]]
 
[[Category:Needs references]]
 
[[Category:Needs references]]
[[Category:Patterns created on the Wiki]]
 
[[Category:Stub]]
 
 
[[Category:To be Published]]
 
[[Category:To be Published]]
[[Category:Staffan's current workpage]]
 
 
''Information provided to players that extends beyond the observational abilities provided by simply observing game elements.''
 
''Information provided to players that extends beyond the observational abilities provided by simply observing game elements.''
  
This pattern is a still a stub.
+
The game elements positions and configuration in a game provide players with information about what they can do. However, complex game states - especially the ones which are maintained in a computer system - may not be able to directly present enough information to players in one continuous and perhaps diegetic presentation. In these cases, additional information can be provided to players through [[Game State Overviews]] which collect and present information in other ways.  
  
 
=== Examples ===
 
=== Examples ===
Example: Most racing games, e. g., Mario Kart Double Dash!! and the Monkey Race party games in the Super Monkey Ball series, provide a small overhead map that shows the location of other players on the track.
+
Many [[:Category:Board Games|Board Games]], e.g. [[Amun-Re]], [[Carcassonne]], [[Dominant Species]], [[Inca Empire]], [[Egizia]], [[Pictionary]], and [[Ursuppe]], include [[Score Tracks]] that help players have a good overview of the positions of all players. [[Ludo]], [[Pachisi]], and [[Snakes and Ladders]] show how this overview can be the game board.  
  
==== Anti-Examples ====
+
Computer-based [[:Category:Strategy Games|Strategy Games]] such as the [[Age of Empires series|Age of Empires]] or [[Civilization (video game) series|Civilization]] series make use of [[Mini-maps]] that allows players to have an overview of a larger part of the game world that would otherwise be possible. Similarly, most [[:Category:Racing Games|Racing Games]], e. g., the [[Mario Kart series]] and the Monkey Race party games in the [[Super Monkey Ball series]], provide a small overhead map that shows the location of other players on the track.
optional
+
  
 
== Using the pattern ==
 
== Using the pattern ==
=== Can Be Instantiated By ===
+
[[Game State Overviews]] are used in games to provide players with information about the game state, e.g. [[Area Control]], [[Negotiation]] contexts, [[Perceivable Margins]], [[Preventing Goals]], [[Player Defined Goals]], or [[Scores]], sometimes to help players know when [[Attention Swapping]] is required. This information may be to help players with [[Movement]], either directly with [[Game World Exploration]], [[Game World Navigation]], [[Reconnaissance]], or [[Traverse]] goals or indirectly with positions in [[Races]]. For [[Combat]] situation, it can provide players with help on [[Tactical Planning]] where [[Camping]] or [[Sniper Locations]] are located while for [[Puzzle Solving]] it can modify [[Memorizing]]. On a more general navigation level, this can be how [[Levels]] are perceived or how [[Fog of War]] functions. For games with [[Units]] it can help players keep track of all the [[Units]] under one's control while in those with [[Player Characters]] it can instead help support [[Identification]]. The presence of [[Game State Overviews]] are likely to affect how players interact with each other in [[Multiplayer Games]], e.g. regarding [[Collaborative Actions]], and well as how [[Perfect Information|Perfect]] or [[Public Information]] is perceived. Of course, [[Game State Overviews]] can also provide information about [[Extra-Game Actions]] since this is part of the game interface which already is outside the diegesis in some way.
[[Auxiliary Game Screens]],  
+
[[Cameras]],  
+
[[Cutscenes]],  
+
[[Dedicated Game Facilitators]],  
+
[[Game State Indicators]],  
+
[[Goal Indicators]],  
+
[[God Views]],  
+
[[Mini-maps]],  
+
[[Narration Structures]],  
+
[[Picture-in-Picture Views]],  
+
[[Privileged Movement]],  
+
[[Score Tracks]],  
+
[[Scores]],  
+
[[Third-Person Views]]
+
  
[[Bookkeeping Tokens]] together with [[Public Information]]
+
The basic elements for providing [[Game State Overviews]] are various [[Game State Indicators]], e.g. [[Bookkeeping Tokens]] (with [[Public Information]]), [[Geospatial Game Widgets]], [[Goal Indicators]], [[Near Miss Indicators]], and [[Score Tracks]] (but publicly observable [[Scores]] can work equally well). [[Auxiliary Game Screens]], [[HUD Interfaces]], [[Mini-maps]], [[Picture-in-Picture Views]], and [[Split-Screen Views]], are more complex solutions which in themselves can provide [[Game State Overviews]] ([[Cutscenes]] and [[Narration Structures]] can also do this but often doesn't present game state information beyond acknowledging that a certain game state has been met since they have been initiated). [[Cameras]], [[God Views]], and [[Third-Person Views]] let players have a form of [[Game State Overview]] in that they are given some agency over what view they should have of the game state (this solution assumes that there is [[Game Worlds]] that a player's point of observation can be manipulated within). [[Privileged Movement]] which allows flying work similarly. [[Dedicated Game Facilitators]] (especially [[Game Masters]]) can of course create [[Game State Overviews]] since they can completely control players' access to what parts of the game state they perceive.
  
[[Game Worlds]] with [[God Views]] or [[Third-Person Views]]
+
[[Alarms]] can modify [[Game State Overviews]] by showing that certain closures are near occurring while [[Outcome Indicators]] can provide detailed information about closures that have occurred. [[Game Pauses]] and [[Turn Taking]] let players that have possibility of observing [[Game State Overviews]] without stress and can thereby make better use of the information they provide.
  
=== Can Be Modulated By ===
+
[[Game State Overviews]] can work against several other design solutions since it can reveal too much information. Examples of patterns which can be negatively affected by [[Game State Overviews]] include [[Game World Navigation]], [[Leaps of Faith]], [[Limited Foresight]], [[Memorizing]], [[Reconnaissance]], and [[Surprises]].
[[Alarms]],
+
[[Outcome Indicators]],
+
[[Turn Taking]]
+
 
+
=== Potentially Conflicting With ===
+
[[Attention Swapping]],
+
[[Game World Navigation]],  
+
[[Leaps of Faith]],  
+
[[Limited Foresight]],  
+
[[Memorizing]],  
+
[[Reconnaissance]],  
+
[[Surprises]]
+
  
 
=== Diegetic Aspects ===
 
=== Diegetic Aspects ===
 +
Since [[Game State Overviews]] often introduce non-diegetic game elements, e.g. through [[Geospatial Game Widgets]] or [[HUD Interfaces]], the pattern often works against [[Diegetic Consistency]].
  
 
=== Interface Aspects ===
 
=== Interface Aspects ===
[[Game State Overviews]] is an [[:Category:Interface Patterns|Interface Pattern]].  
+
[[Game State Overviews]] is an [[:Category:Interface Patterns|Interface Pattern]].
 
+
=== Narration Aspects ===
+
  
 
== Consequences ==
 
== Consequences ==
=== Can Instantiate ===
+
[[Game State Overviews]] typically work as [[Progress Indicators]]. Since they can provide players with information about their own situation and that of other players, it can help provide [[Strategic Knowledge]] and create [[Stimulated Planning]] and [[Cognitive Engrossment]]. This can in [[Turn-Based Games|Turn-Based]] [[Multiplayer Games]] cause [[Analysis Paralysis]] but can also in [[Multiplayer Games]] have [[Balancing Effects]] if either [[Player Decided Results]] or [[Player-Decided Distributions]] exist. However since it can provide information about other aspects of the game state than what a player is currently engage with it can also cause [[Disruption of Focused Attention]].
[[Cognitive Engrossment]],
+
[[Disruption of Focused Attention]],
+
[[Progress Indicators]],
+
[[Spectators]],
+
[[Speedending]],
+
[[Stimulated Planning]],
+
[[Strategic Knowledge]],
+
[[Races]]
+
  
==== with [[Game Worlds]] ====
+
Providing players with information about their own and other players' positions can cause them to perceive the gameplay as [[Races]], and make players try [[Speedending]] the games if it is to their advantage. When the [[Game State Overviews]] are available to others than the players, it supports games to have [[Spectators]].
[[Alignment]]
+
 
+
==== with [[Multiplayer Games]] and either [[Player Decided Results]] or [[Player-Decided Distributions]] ====
+
[[Balancing Effects]]
+
 
+
==== with [[Multiplayer Games]] and [[Turn-Based Games]] ====
+
[[Analysis Paralysis]]
+
 
+
=== Can Modulate ===
+
[[Area Control]],
+
[[Attention Swapping]],
+
[[Camping]],
+
[[Collaborative Actions]],
+
[[Extra-Game Actions]],
+
[[Fog of War]],
+
[[Game World Exploration]],
+
[[Game World Navigation]],
+
[[Identification]],
+
[[Memorizing]],
+
[[Movement]],
+
[[Multiplayer Games]],
+
[[Near Miss Indicators]],
+
[[Negotiation]],
+
[[Levels]],
+
[[Perceivable Margins]],
+
[[Perfect Information]],
+
[[Player Defined Goals]],
+
[[Preventing Goals]],
+
[[Public Information]],
+
[[Puzzle Solving]],
+
[[Races]],
+
[[Reconnaissance]],
+
[[Sniper Locations]],
+
[[Split-Screen Views]],
+
[[Tactical Planning]],
+
[[Traverse]],  
+
[[Units]]
+
  
 
== Relations ==
 
== Relations ==
Line 122: Line 45:
 
[[Strategic Knowledge]],  
 
[[Strategic Knowledge]],  
 
[[Races]]
 
[[Races]]
 
==== with [[Game Worlds]] ====
 
[[Alignment]]
 
  
 
==== with [[Multiplayer Games]] and either [[Player Decided Results]] or [[Player-Decided Distributions]] ====
 
==== with [[Multiplayer Games]] and either [[Player Decided Results]] or [[Player-Decided Distributions]] ====
Line 131: Line 51:
 
==== with [[Multiplayer Games]] and [[Turn-Based Games]] ====
 
==== with [[Multiplayer Games]] and [[Turn-Based Games]] ====
 
[[Analysis Paralysis]]
 
[[Analysis Paralysis]]
 +
 +
==== with [[Player Characters]] ====
 +
[[Identification]]
  
 
=== Can Modulate ===
 
=== Can Modulate ===
Line 141: Line 64:
 
[[Game World Exploration]],  
 
[[Game World Exploration]],  
 
[[Game World Navigation]],  
 
[[Game World Navigation]],  
[[Identification]],
 
 
[[Memorizing]],  
 
[[Memorizing]],  
 
[[Movement]],  
 
[[Movement]],  
 
[[Multiplayer Games]],  
 
[[Multiplayer Games]],  
[[Near Miss Indicators]],
 
 
[[Negotiation]],  
 
[[Negotiation]],  
 
[[Levels]],  
 
[[Levels]],  
Line 157: Line 78:
 
[[Reconnaissance]],  
 
[[Reconnaissance]],  
 
[[Sniper Locations]],  
 
[[Sniper Locations]],  
[[Split-Screen Views]],
 
 
[[Tactical Planning]],  
 
[[Tactical Planning]],  
 
[[Traverse]],  
 
[[Traverse]],  
Line 170: Line 90:
 
[[Goal Indicators]],  
 
[[Goal Indicators]],  
 
[[God Views]],  
 
[[God Views]],  
 +
[[HUD Interfaces]],
 
[[Mini-maps]],  
 
[[Mini-maps]],  
 
[[Narration Structures]],  
 
[[Narration Structures]],  
 +
[[Near Miss Indicators]],
 
[[Picture-in-Picture Views]],  
 
[[Picture-in-Picture Views]],  
 
[[Privileged Movement]],  
 
[[Privileged Movement]],  
 
[[Score Tracks]],  
 
[[Score Tracks]],  
 
[[Scores]],  
 
[[Scores]],  
 +
[[Split-Screen Views]],
 
[[Third-Person Views]]
 
[[Third-Person Views]]
  
Line 184: Line 107:
 
=== Can Be Modulated By ===
 
=== Can Be Modulated By ===
 
[[Alarms]],  
 
[[Alarms]],  
 +
[[Game Pauses]],
 
[[Outcome Indicators]],  
 
[[Outcome Indicators]],  
 
[[Turn Taking]]
 
[[Turn Taking]]
Line 191: Line 115:
  
 
=== Potentially Conflicting With ===
 
=== Potentially Conflicting With ===
[[Attention Swapping]],  
+
[[Diegetic Consistency]],  
 
[[Game World Navigation]],  
 
[[Game World Navigation]],  
 
[[Leaps of Faith]],  
 
[[Leaps of Faith]],  

Latest revision as of 07:49, 19 July 2016

Information provided to players that extends beyond the observational abilities provided by simply observing game elements.

The game elements positions and configuration in a game provide players with information about what they can do. However, complex game states - especially the ones which are maintained in a computer system - may not be able to directly present enough information to players in one continuous and perhaps diegetic presentation. In these cases, additional information can be provided to players through Game State Overviews which collect and present information in other ways.

Examples

Many Board Games, e.g. Amun-Re, Carcassonne, Dominant Species, Inca Empire, Egizia, Pictionary, and Ursuppe, include Score Tracks that help players have a good overview of the positions of all players. Ludo, Pachisi, and Snakes and Ladders show how this overview can be the game board.

Computer-based Strategy Games such as the Age of Empires or Civilization series make use of Mini-maps that allows players to have an overview of a larger part of the game world that would otherwise be possible. Similarly, most Racing Games, e. g., the Mario Kart series and the Monkey Race party games in the Super Monkey Ball series, provide a small overhead map that shows the location of other players on the track.

Using the pattern

Game State Overviews are used in games to provide players with information about the game state, e.g. Area Control, Negotiation contexts, Perceivable Margins, Preventing Goals, Player Defined Goals, or Scores, sometimes to help players know when Attention Swapping is required. This information may be to help players with Movement, either directly with Game World Exploration, Game World Navigation, Reconnaissance, or Traverse goals or indirectly with positions in Races. For Combat situation, it can provide players with help on Tactical Planning where Camping or Sniper Locations are located while for Puzzle Solving it can modify Memorizing. On a more general navigation level, this can be how Levels are perceived or how Fog of War functions. For games with Units it can help players keep track of all the Units under one's control while in those with Player Characters it can instead help support Identification. The presence of Game State Overviews are likely to affect how players interact with each other in Multiplayer Games, e.g. regarding Collaborative Actions, and well as how Perfect or Public Information is perceived. Of course, Game State Overviews can also provide information about Extra-Game Actions since this is part of the game interface which already is outside the diegesis in some way.

The basic elements for providing Game State Overviews are various Game State Indicators, e.g. Bookkeeping Tokens (with Public Information), Geospatial Game Widgets, Goal Indicators, Near Miss Indicators, and Score Tracks (but publicly observable Scores can work equally well). Auxiliary Game Screens, HUD Interfaces, Mini-maps, Picture-in-Picture Views, and Split-Screen Views, are more complex solutions which in themselves can provide Game State Overviews (Cutscenes and Narration Structures can also do this but often doesn't present game state information beyond acknowledging that a certain game state has been met since they have been initiated). Cameras, God Views, and Third-Person Views let players have a form of Game State Overview in that they are given some agency over what view they should have of the game state (this solution assumes that there is Game Worlds that a player's point of observation can be manipulated within). Privileged Movement which allows flying work similarly. Dedicated Game Facilitators (especially Game Masters) can of course create Game State Overviews since they can completely control players' access to what parts of the game state they perceive.

Alarms can modify Game State Overviews by showing that certain closures are near occurring while Outcome Indicators can provide detailed information about closures that have occurred. Game Pauses and Turn Taking let players that have possibility of observing Game State Overviews without stress and can thereby make better use of the information they provide.

Game State Overviews can work against several other design solutions since it can reveal too much information. Examples of patterns which can be negatively affected by Game State Overviews include Game World Navigation, Leaps of Faith, Limited Foresight, Memorizing, Reconnaissance, and Surprises.

Diegetic Aspects

Since Game State Overviews often introduce non-diegetic game elements, e.g. through Geospatial Game Widgets or HUD Interfaces, the pattern often works against Diegetic Consistency.

Interface Aspects

Game State Overviews is an Interface Pattern.

Consequences

Game State Overviews typically work as Progress Indicators. Since they can provide players with information about their own situation and that of other players, it can help provide Strategic Knowledge and create Stimulated Planning and Cognitive Engrossment. This can in Turn-Based Multiplayer Games cause Analysis Paralysis but can also in Multiplayer Games have Balancing Effects if either Player Decided Results or Player-Decided Distributions exist. However since it can provide information about other aspects of the game state than what a player is currently engage with it can also cause Disruption of Focused Attention.

Providing players with information about their own and other players' positions can cause them to perceive the gameplay as Races, and make players try Speedending the games if it is to their advantage. When the Game State Overviews are available to others than the players, it supports games to have Spectators.

Relations

Can Instantiate

Cognitive Engrossment, Disruption of Focused Attention, Progress Indicators, Spectators, Speedending, Stimulated Planning, Strategic Knowledge, Races

with Multiplayer Games and either Player Decided Results or Player-Decided Distributions

Balancing Effects

with Multiplayer Games and Turn-Based Games

Analysis Paralysis

with Player Characters

Identification

Can Modulate

Area Control, Attention Swapping, Camping, Collaborative Actions, Extra-Game Actions, Fog of War, Game World Exploration, Game World Navigation, Memorizing, Movement, Multiplayer Games, Negotiation, Levels, Perceivable Margins, Perfect Information, Player Defined Goals, Preventing Goals, Public Information, Puzzle Solving, Races, Reconnaissance, Sniper Locations, Tactical Planning, Traverse, Units

Can Be Instantiated By

Auxiliary Game Screens, Cameras, Cutscenes, Dedicated Game Facilitators, Game State Indicators, Goal Indicators, God Views, HUD Interfaces, Mini-maps, Narration Structures, Near Miss Indicators, Picture-in-Picture Views, Privileged Movement, Score Tracks, Scores, Split-Screen Views, Third-Person Views

Bookkeeping Tokens together with Public Information

Game Worlds with God Views or Third-Person Views

Can Be Modulated By

Alarms, Game Pauses, Outcome Indicators, Turn Taking

Possible Closure Effects

-

Potentially Conflicting With

Diegetic Consistency, Game World Navigation, Leaps of Faith, Limited Foresight, Memorizing, Reconnaissance, Surprises

History

An updated version of the pattern Game State Overview that was part of the original collection in the book Patterns in Game Design[1].

References

  1. Björk, S. & Holopainen, J. (2004) Patterns in Game Design. Charles River Media. ISBN1-58450-354-8.

Acknowledgements

-