Difference between revisions of "Repetitive Gameplay"
(→Consequences) |
(→Examples) |
||
| (8 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
[[Category:Dynamic Patterns]] | [[Category:Dynamic Patterns]] | ||
[[Category:Negative Patterns]] | [[Category:Negative Patterns]] | ||
| − | |||
[[Category:Needs revision]] | [[Category:Needs revision]] | ||
[[Category:Needs examples]] | [[Category:Needs examples]] | ||
[[Category:Needs references]] | [[Category:Needs references]] | ||
[[Category:Patterns created on the Wiki]] | [[Category:Patterns created on the Wiki]] | ||
| − | |||
[[Category:To be Published]] | [[Category:To be Published]] | ||
| − | + | ''Gameplay that requires the same type of actions or choice repeatedly to a player.'' | |
| − | ' | + | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| + | Games provide possible actions to players, and these have to be related to each other in some way for players to judge a game as being one game. However, when the actions are the same or very similar and players need to perform them repeatedly the game can be said to have [[Repetitive Gameplay]]. | ||
=== Examples === | === Examples === | ||
| + | Many ''roll and move'' [[:Category:Board Games|Board Games]], e.g. [[Monopoly]] and [[Pachisi]], require players to do the same game action every time it is their turn. Even if they can have some freedom of choice, for example to buy or not buy land or choose which token to move, they will be doing the same gameplay action the next time it is their turn. | ||
| − | + | Many early [[:Category:Arcade Games|Arcade Games]] by necessity had [[Repetitive Gameplay]]. Examples include [[Asteroids]], [[Donkey Kong]], [[Pac-Man]], and [[Pong]]. | |
| − | + | ||
| + | The [[Dance Dance Revolution series]] and the [[Rock Band series]] has [[Repetitive Gameplay]] in that players only have a very limited number of actions that they need to perform the same way every time a particular track is played. | ||
== Using the pattern == | == Using the pattern == | ||
| − | [[Repetitive Gameplay]] is often seen as something bad in a game, if for nothing else that it will limit the novelty and potential for [[Gameplay Mastery]] when the gameplay provided has been mastered. However, [[Repetitive Gameplay]] also lets players train on that gameplay (which can support learning [[Gameplay Mastery]] and support [[Cognitive Engrossment|Cognitive]], [[Sensory-Motoric Engrossment|Sensory-Motoric]], or [[Spatial Engrossment]]. | + | [[Repetitive Gameplay]] is often seen as something bad in a game, if for nothing else that it will limit the novelty and potential for [[Gameplay Mastery]] when the gameplay provided has been mastered. However, [[Repetitive Gameplay]] also lets players train on that gameplay (which can support learning [[Gameplay Mastery]] and support [[Cognitive Engrossment|Cognitive]], [[Sensory-Motoric Engrossment|Sensory-Motoric]], or [[Spatial Engrossment]]. It should be noted that [[Repetitive Gameplay]] can be viewed as applying to the whole gameplay — like in [[Asteroids]] and [[Pac-Man]] — or more localized by for example having certain [[Levels]] require a certain type of actions. |
| + | |||
| + | [[Generic Adversaries]], [[Grinding]], [[Micromanagement]], [[Pottering]], and [[Rhythm-Based Actions]] are general ways of enticing [[Repetitive Gameplay]]. However, [[Repetitive Gameplay]] can occur in any game so those wishing to avoid it while creating a game need to test if this occurs with play tests. In some games [[Repetitive Gameplay]] can occur due to the best possible actions for players make them recreate previous game states. One way of handle this is to use [[Repetition of Position Draws]], i.e. making a game end in a draw if the same game state is repeated enough times. [[Chess]] does if a position occurs three times while [[Shogi]] does it if a position occurs four times. [[Go]] instead has the 'rule of ko' to prohibit immediate recreation of the previous position after an opponent's move. This does however not avoid [[Repetitive Gameplay]] overall since several ''ko'' positions can together create endless cycles. This occurs rarely enough that few players need to care about this, but several [[Go]] organizations have ''superko'' rules forbidding the recreation of any previous game state. | ||
| − | + | [[Repetitive Gameplay]] can also occur due to games being used in other games. That is, any game used in a [[Tournaments|Tournament]] while have [[Repetitive Gameplay]] in the meaning that the same game will be played multiple times (depending on how many times every player gets to play). Also, the use of [[Minigames]] can make for [[Repetitive Gameplay]] as the "outer" game may force players to play the [[Minigames]] many times or players may choose to do so themselves. | |
=== Narration Aspects === | === Narration Aspects === | ||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
== Consequences == | == Consequences == | ||
| − | [[Repetitive Gameplay]] has a volatile relation with [[Value of Effort]]; it can both cause players to feel that there is little [[Value of Effort]] in a game and cause players to feel they have achieved something because they have endured or handled it. Games with [[Grinding]] shows this most clearly since the [[Repetitive Gameplay]] that [[Grinding]] offers or requires can provoke both these types of experiences. [[Repetitive Gameplay]] can also work against [[Player Agency]] since it by definition forces players to have a particular type of gameplay, and this gameplay may have few possibilities for players to choose how to play. | + | [[Repetitive Gameplay]] has a volatile relation with [[Value of Effort]]; it can both cause players to feel that there is little [[Value of Effort]] in a game and cause players to feel they have achieved something because they have endured or handled it. Games with [[Grinding]] shows this most clearly since the [[Repetitive Gameplay]] that [[Grinding]] offers or requires can provoke both these types of experiences. [[Repetitive Gameplay]] can also work against [[Freedom of Choice]] and [[Player Agency]] since it by definition forces players to have a particular type of gameplay, and this gameplay may have few possibilities for players to choose how to play. |
== Relations == | == Relations == | ||
| Line 45: | Line 45: | ||
[[Grinding]], | [[Grinding]], | ||
[[Micromanagement]], | [[Micromanagement]], | ||
| − | [[Pottering]] | + | [[Minigames]], |
| + | [[Pottering]], | ||
| + | [[Rhythm-Based Actions]], | ||
| + | [[Tournaments]] | ||
=== Can Be Modulated By === | === Can Be Modulated By === | ||
| Line 54: | Line 57: | ||
=== Potentially Conflicting With === | === Potentially Conflicting With === | ||
| + | [[Freedom of Choice]], | ||
[[Player Agency]], | [[Player Agency]], | ||
[[Value of Effort]] | [[Value of Effort]] | ||
Latest revision as of 15:53, 15 August 2016
Gameplay that requires the same type of actions or choice repeatedly to a player.
Games provide possible actions to players, and these have to be related to each other in some way for players to judge a game as being one game. However, when the actions are the same or very similar and players need to perform them repeatedly the game can be said to have Repetitive Gameplay.
Contents
Examples
Many roll and move Board Games, e.g. Monopoly and Pachisi, require players to do the same game action every time it is their turn. Even if they can have some freedom of choice, for example to buy or not buy land or choose which token to move, they will be doing the same gameplay action the next time it is their turn.
Many early Arcade Games by necessity had Repetitive Gameplay. Examples include Asteroids, Donkey Kong, Pac-Man, and Pong.
The Dance Dance Revolution series and the Rock Band series has Repetitive Gameplay in that players only have a very limited number of actions that they need to perform the same way every time a particular track is played.
Using the pattern
Repetitive Gameplay is often seen as something bad in a game, if for nothing else that it will limit the novelty and potential for Gameplay Mastery when the gameplay provided has been mastered. However, Repetitive Gameplay also lets players train on that gameplay (which can support learning Gameplay Mastery and support Cognitive, Sensory-Motoric, or Spatial Engrossment. It should be noted that Repetitive Gameplay can be viewed as applying to the whole gameplay — like in Asteroids and Pac-Man — or more localized by for example having certain Levels require a certain type of actions.
Generic Adversaries, Grinding, Micromanagement, Pottering, and Rhythm-Based Actions are general ways of enticing Repetitive Gameplay. However, Repetitive Gameplay can occur in any game so those wishing to avoid it while creating a game need to test if this occurs with play tests. In some games Repetitive Gameplay can occur due to the best possible actions for players make them recreate previous game states. One way of handle this is to use Repetition of Position Draws, i.e. making a game end in a draw if the same game state is repeated enough times. Chess does if a position occurs three times while Shogi does it if a position occurs four times. Go instead has the 'rule of ko' to prohibit immediate recreation of the previous position after an opponent's move. This does however not avoid Repetitive Gameplay overall since several ko positions can together create endless cycles. This occurs rarely enough that few players need to care about this, but several Go organizations have superko rules forbidding the recreation of any previous game state.
Repetitive Gameplay can also occur due to games being used in other games. That is, any game used in a Tournament while have Repetitive Gameplay in the meaning that the same game will be played multiple times (depending on how many times every player gets to play). Also, the use of Minigames can make for Repetitive Gameplay as the "outer" game may force players to play the Minigames many times or players may choose to do so themselves.
Narration Aspects
Repetitive Gameplay can be difficult to combine with Narration Structures unless they are also based upon cyclic repetition, e.g. the story structures in the movies Groundhog Day or Edge of Tomorrow. While The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask does have such as structure, the amount of gameplay available in each cycle makes this game not have Repetitive Gameplay.
Consequences
Repetitive Gameplay has a volatile relation with Value of Effort; it can both cause players to feel that there is little Value of Effort in a game and cause players to feel they have achieved something because they have endured or handled it. Games with Grinding shows this most clearly since the Repetitive Gameplay that Grinding offers or requires can provoke both these types of experiences. Repetitive Gameplay can also work against Freedom of Choice and Player Agency since it by definition forces players to have a particular type of gameplay, and this gameplay may have few possibilities for players to choose how to play.
Relations
Can Instantiate
Cognitive Engrossment, Sensory-Motoric Engrossment, Spatial Engrossment, Value of Effort
Can Modulate
Can Be Instantiated By
Generic Adversaries, Grinding, Micromanagement, Minigames, Pottering, Rhythm-Based Actions, Tournaments
Can Be Modulated By
Possible Closure Effects
-
Potentially Conflicting With
Freedom of Choice, Player Agency, Value of Effort
History
New pattern created in this wiki.
References
-
Acknowledgements
-
