Difference between revisions of "Strategic Planning"

Revision as of 15:47, 13 September 2011

Planning based solely on knowledge of game rules and the abilities of other players.

Most games allow or require players to plan what they want to do later in them. Strategic Planning takes place when this planning is only loosely based upon the current gameplay situation and more on general patterns of gameplay and large scale effects.

Note: definitions of strategy and tactics vary. For this collection of patterns, strategy refers to aspects of games that do not depend on any specific game state while tactics relate to how one acts on specific game states.

Examples

Strategy Games and Wargames depend on both tactical and Strategic Planning, with the importance of the latter typically being more significant in the beginning of gameplay and the former being more significant in endgames. Examples of these games are numerous, ranging from the ancient Chess, Go, Hnefatafl, Kriegsspiel, and Mahjong to the more modern Diplomacy, Hex, Reversi, Risk, and Stratego. Computer-based examples such as Civilization, Europa Universalis, Hearts of Iron, and Victoria series can add additional complexity to these games through having the computer handle the bookkeeping necessary for supporting huge numbers of units.

Zero-Player Games can be considered for only consist of Strategic Planning and setting up the game system in advance so that the planning is executed properly. 4 Minutes and 33 Seconds of Uniqueness can likewise be seen as only consisting of the gameplay action of beginning the game when, according to Strategic Planning, no other players is likely to begin playing the game soon.

Using the pattern

In contrast with Tactical Planning, which depends on specific game states, Strategic Planning depends on general structures of the game design. Both are however likely to affect each other so considering them together may be prudent. The basic requirement for Strategic Planning is that players can have Strategic Knowledge about the game and that they have a Freedom of Choice of what strategy to use during gameplay. Since this is typically achieved through playing the games, having Replayability supports Strategic Planning (actually, not having Replayability probably indicates that players can do Strategic Planning perfectly but this also removes the possibility for them to have any Freedom of Choice). Generally speaking, Predictable Consequences supports Strategic Planning since players can more easily find general structures in the gameplay.

Having Strategic Locations in games is one way to allow players to develop Strategic Knowledge and thereby be able to do Strategic Planning. Examples of Strategic Locations suitable for supporting Strategic Planning due to how they affect gameplay actions include Choke Points, Installations, Safe Havens, and those that support Camping. Knowing which Weapons or Powers that Enemies have Vulnerabilities to - or can exploit Achilles' Heels - is example of another type of Strategic Knowledge that can let players do Strategic Planning is advance of Combat.

Knowing how to set up their part of game instances with Heterogeneous Game Element Ownership, e.g. through Deck Building, to create Combos is another way in which players can do Strategic Planning based upon their Strategic Knowledge. Privileged Abilities cannot be used in this sense since players may not know which other players have which abilities so they may not be privileged, but when abilities are predetermined those that then are Privileged Abilities can be the basis for Strategic Planning.

Randomness can hinder the knowledge of these strategic aspects, but knowing the probabilities used can in turn represent Strategic Knowledge on a higher level. Related to this, Limited Planning Abilities can works against Strategic Planning but Limited Foresight is not as likely to interfere with this type of planning since the foresight has more to do with tactical issues.

Strategic Planning can be the sole activity possible in games. This is the case when the intention is to make Zero-Player Games, often in the form of giving players the Creative Control to construct Algorithmic Agents.

Interface Aspects

One way of supporting Strategic Planning is to make Strategic Knowledge available through the game interface. Since this knowledge typically takes too much space to be shown all at once during gameplay, it can instead be made accessible through Secondary Interface Screens, Tool Tips, or Loading Hints (see the Civilization series for an example of the first pattern and the Europa Universalis series for the two other patterns).

Consequences

The possibility to do Strategic Planning leads to Stimulated Planning in games, including planning as Extra-Game Activities. When planning does take place during gameplay in Multiplayer Games that are and Turn-Based, this can lead to Analysis Paralysis since other players are forced to have Downtime.

While Replayability is often a requirement for Strategic Planning since the primary way of learning game systems are through interacting with them, Strategic Planning also modulates Replayability since players can consider ways of improving their gameplay. This can lead to Varied Gameplay as players try different strategies.

Relations

Can Instantiate

Extra-Game Activities, Stimulated Planning, Zero-Player Games

with Multiplayer Games and Turn-Based Games

Analysis Paralysis, Downtime

with Replayability

Varied Gameplay

Can Modulate

Replayability

Can Be Instantiated By

Camping, Deck Building, Freedom of Choice, Predictable Consequences, Privileged Abilities, Replayability, Strategic Knowledge, Strategic Locations

Achilles' Heels together with Powers or Weapons

Algorithmic Agents together with Creative Control

Combos together with Heterogeneous Game Element Ownership

Strategic Knowledge together with Loading Hints, Secondary Interface Screens, or Tool Tips

Vulnerabilities together with Powers or Weapons

Can Be Modulated By

-

Possible Closure Effects

-

Potentially Conflicting With

Limited Planning Abilities, Randomness

History

New pattern created in this wiki.

References

-