FUBAR Enjoyment
The enjoyment experienced when things are not going your way, but you are still in the fight; a specific type of tension.
Games typically challenge players in different ways. FUBAR[1] Enjoyment can occur when these challenges rely on players being overwhelmed with things they need to react to while also being under time pressure, either because the pure amount of things become ridiculous or that players notice that they are somehow handling the situation. This FUBAR Enjoyment can be seen as a flow experience[2] that presses against the competences of a player to the degree that failure seems imminent.
Contents
Examples
Shoot 'em up Games such as 1942 and Tempest forces players to fight many enemies at the same time, having to both try and hit them while avoiding to get hit by the multiple shots fired at them. The subgenre of "Bullet Hell"[3] games rely even more on FUBAR Enjoyment that the other Shoot 'em up Games.
Even if players only need to deal with one block at a time, the pure speed with which players need to react in Tetris can evoke FUBAR Enjoyment. As an example using a different design approach to promote FUBAR Enjoyment, zombie-based games such as the Left 4 Dead series and Dead Rising series rely on players meeting huge number of enemies which try to rush the players' characters and engage in close combat.
Using the pattern
Can Be Instantiated By
Attention Demanding, Attention Swapping, Challenging Gameplay, Complex Gameplay, Ever Increasing Difficulty,
Disruption of Focused Attention, Hovering Closures, Limited Foresight, Limited Planning Ability, Real-Time Games, Simultaneous Challenges, Survive, The Show Must Go On
Diegetic Aspects
Interface Aspects
Narration Aspects
Consequences
While FUBAR Enjoyment is a positive experience, it relies on players having Cognitive Engrossment and Tension. One reason why FUBAR Enjoyment is enjoyable is that it lets players feel that they have Gameplay Mastery and it can be argued that the pattern does make players have this since they need to play at their full abilities; another reason is that eventual failure can lead to Spectacular Failure Enjoyment since the situation was chaotic or very difficult to begin with. Regardless, games with FUBAR Enjoyment have Performance Uncertainty since players are forced to act in situations where not succeeding is a very possible outcome.
For Multiplayer Games, the combination of FUBAR Enjoyment with either Parties, PvE, or Teams leads to the possibility of Mutual FUBAR Enjoyment.
Relations
Can Instantiate
Cognitive Engrossment, Gameplay Mastery, Performance Uncertainty, Spectacular Failure Enjoyment, Tension
with Parties, PvE, or Teams in Multiplayer Games
Can Modulate
-
Can Be Instantiated By
Attention Demanding, Attention Swapping, Challenging Gameplay, Complex Gameplay, Ever Increasing Difficulty, Disruption of Focused Attention, Hovering Closures, Limited Foresight, Limited Planning Ability, Real-Time Games, Simultaneous Challenges, Survive, The Show Must Go On
Can Be Modulated By
-
Possible Closure Effects
-
Potentially Conflicting With
-
History
Updated version of the pattern "Spectacular Failure Enjoyment" first described in the paper Exploring aesthetical gameplay design patterns: camaraderie in four games[4].
References
- ↑ US miliary slang: F***ed Up Beyond Recognition.
- ↑ Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly (1990). Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience. New York: Harper and Row.
- ↑ Wikipedia subentry entry for Bullet Hell.
- ↑ Bergström, K., Björk, S. & Lundgren, S. 2010. Exploring aesthetical gameplay design patterns: camaraderie in four games. In Proceedings of MindTrek 2010.
Acknowledgments
-
