Difference between revisions of "Crafting"
(→Relations) |
|||
| (12 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
[[Category:Needs references]] | [[Category:Needs references]] | ||
[[Category:Patterns created on the Wiki]] | [[Category:Patterns created on the Wiki]] | ||
| − | |||
''The activity of creating game items.'' | ''The activity of creating game items.'' | ||
| Line 18: | Line 17: | ||
== Using the pattern == | == Using the pattern == | ||
| − | The | + | The design choices associated with creating [[Crafting]] in a game are primarily what is required to engage in the [[Crafting]] activity and what [[Game Items]] are constructed from the action, alternatively how can one improve the quality of functionality of some [[Game Items]]. [[Crafting]] is often modulated by [[Creative Control]] in that players may be able to choose which [[Game Items]] to produce from the [[Resources]] at hand. |
| − | [[Crafting]] consists of transforming something into something else, so some form of [[Resources]] | + | [[Crafting]] consists of improving something or transforming something into something else, so requiring that some form of [[Resources]] is consumed in the process is quite natural and common. To limit who can do the [[Crafting]], or when it can be done, game designs can require use of [[Tools]] or that those doing the action have specific [[Skills]] or [[Privileged Abilities]]. A more specific form of the latter can be to require that some actions are done by [[Neighbors]]. Making use of stationary [[Tools]], i.e. [[Installations]], for [[Crafting]], makes possibilities to craft into [[Location-Fixed Abilities]] ([[Minecraft]] does this for crafting larger items). Making the [[Construction]] of each [[Game Items|Game Item]] have a [[Development Time]] or require [[Extended Actions]] can modulate how often new items can occur. Besides allowing the [[Crafting]] to begin with, the use of [[Skills]] or particular [[Tools]] can also be used to influence the quality of the produced [[Game Items]], the use of [[Resources]], and the time taken to finish the action. |
| − | Any type of [[Game Items]] can be the result of [[Crafting]], but [[Tools]] is worth mentioning as a subcategory since it may be required for players to engage in other types of [[Crafting]] and thereby can set up development chains where the [[New Abilities]] gained can be seen as a form of [[Character Development]]. For some types of [[Game Items]], e.g. [[Ammunition]], it can be worth considering that each completed [[Crafting]] action provides not one but several instances of the [[Game Items]]. | + | Any type of [[Game Items]] can be the result of [[Crafting]], but [[Tools]] is worth mentioning as a subcategory since it may be required for players to engage in other types of [[Crafting]] and thereby can set up development chains where the [[New Abilities]] gained can be seen as a form of [[Character Development]]. For some types of [[Game Items]], e.g. [[Ammunition]], it can be worth considering that each completed [[Crafting]] action provides not one but several instances of the [[Game Items]]. When [[Crafting]] is instead used to modify existing [[Game Items]] this is most often to either counter [[Deterioration]] or give [[New Abilities|New]] or [[Improved Abilities]] - [[Upgrades]] and [[Sidegrades]] are specific examples of the latter. |
| + | |||
| + | The actions making [[Crafting]] possible can be [[Extra-Game Actions]] if they only can take place before gameplay begins. | ||
=== Diegetic Aspects === | === Diegetic Aspects === | ||
| Line 31: | Line 32: | ||
== Consequences == | == Consequences == | ||
| − | [[Crafting]] provides a way for players or other [[Agents]] to engage in the [[Construction]] of [[Game Items]] in [[Game Worlds]]. | + | [[Crafting]] provides a way for players or other [[Agents]] to engage in the [[Construction]] of [[Game Items]] in [[Game Worlds]], quite likely resulting in [[Player Created Game Elements]]. Performing [[Crafting]] activities can be seen as making [[Investments]] since [[Resources]] are usually consumed while engaging in [[Crafting]] (if nothing else, gameplay time is consumed). [[Crafting]] makes those that engage in it into [[Converters]], and when [[Tools]] or crafted [[Game Items]] are required to engage in other types of [[Crafting]], this sets up [[Production-Consumption Chains]]. When this is kept to one [[Focus Loci]], this provides a form of [[Character Development]]. In games with [[Persistent Game Worlds]] of [[Multiplayer Games]], both this type of [[Crafting]] and repetitious "basic" [[Crafting]] can disrupt both the economy within the game and the [[Player Balance]] if not the effort to create [[Game Items]] is balanced with the value of them. |
| − | + | When [[Creative Control]] is given to players regarding [[Crafting]], as for example in [[Minecraft]] or [[Slaves to Armok II: Dwarf Fortress]], this gives them [[Framed Freedom]] and [[Constructive Gameplay]]. The knowledge of what [[Game Items]] can be construct, and what is required to do this, can be [[Strategic Knowledge]]. The possibility of [[Agents]] to create artifacts can be a vital component in explaining civilizations in [[Game Worlds]], and therefore help instantiate [[Thematic Consistency]] (although of course only artifacts which are consistent with the theme should be possible to create). | |
| − | + | Being an activity that does not inherently need to have risks involved or require player skills, [[Crafting]] can easily open up for [[Grinding]]. However, it can give some worth to other forms of [[Grinding]], e.g. that of [[Collecting]] resources. | |
== Relations == | == Relations == | ||
| Line 42: | Line 43: | ||
[[Constructive Gameplay]], | [[Constructive Gameplay]], | ||
[[Converters]], | [[Converters]], | ||
| − | [[ | + | [[Extra-Game Actions]], |
| − | [[ | + | [[Improved Abilities]], |
| + | [[Investments]], | ||
| + | [[New Abilities]], | ||
| + | [[Player Created Game Elements]], | ||
| + | [[Thematic Consistency]], | ||
[[Grinding]], | [[Grinding]], | ||
| + | [[Privileged Abilities]], | ||
[[Strategic Knowledge]] | [[Strategic Knowledge]] | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==== with [[Creative Control]] ==== | ||
| + | [[Framed Freedom]] | ||
==== with [[Tools]] ==== | ==== with [[Tools]] ==== | ||
| Line 52: | Line 61: | ||
=== Can Modulate === | === Can Modulate === | ||
| + | [[Collecting]], | ||
| + | [[Deterioration]], | ||
[[Game Items]], | [[Game Items]], | ||
[[Game Worlds]], | [[Game Worlds]], | ||
| Line 63: | Line 74: | ||
=== Can Be Modulated By === | === Can Be Modulated By === | ||
| + | [[Creative Control]], | ||
[[Development Time]], | [[Development Time]], | ||
[[Extended Actions]], | [[Extended Actions]], | ||
| + | [[Neighbors]], | ||
[[Resources]], | [[Resources]], | ||
| + | [[Sidegrades]], | ||
[[Skills]], | [[Skills]], | ||
| − | [[Tools]] | + | [[Tools]], |
| + | [[Upgrades]] | ||
=== Possible Closure Effects === | === Possible Closure Effects === | ||
| Line 73: | Line 88: | ||
=== Potentially Conflicting With === | === Potentially Conflicting With === | ||
| − | [[Player Balance]] in games with [[Persistent Game Worlds]] | + | [[Player Balance]] in games with [[Persistent Game Worlds]] in [[Multiplayer Games]] |
== History == | == History == | ||
Latest revision as of 08:12, 17 June 2022
The activity of creating game items.
Crafting is the activity of creating game items within game worlds through actions. By allowing these activities, games explain how the items come to be in the worlds as well as offer players the possibility to engage in a constructive activity.
Contents
Examples
Crafting is most often found in Massively Multiplayer Online Games such as Entropia Universe, Eve Online, Ultima Online, and World of Warcraft. Here, players can craft weapons, armor, and tools depending on the setting.
Players of Slaves to Armok II: Dwarf Fortress start with a small cache of items but need to craft more for their dwarves having a chance to survive; in Minecraft players need to craft all tools they wish to use. Zombie Lane allows players to buy more powerful weapons that the default shovel, but also that they can create special types of weapons through Crafting.
The Fable series let players engage in mini-games that are diegetically presented as crafting but doesn't actually create game items.
Using the pattern
The design choices associated with creating Crafting in a game are primarily what is required to engage in the Crafting activity and what Game Items are constructed from the action, alternatively how can one improve the quality of functionality of some Game Items. Crafting is often modulated by Creative Control in that players may be able to choose which Game Items to produce from the Resources at hand.
Crafting consists of improving something or transforming something into something else, so requiring that some form of Resources is consumed in the process is quite natural and common. To limit who can do the Crafting, or when it can be done, game designs can require use of Tools or that those doing the action have specific Skills or Privileged Abilities. A more specific form of the latter can be to require that some actions are done by Neighbors. Making use of stationary Tools, i.e. Installations, for Crafting, makes possibilities to craft into Location-Fixed Abilities (Minecraft does this for crafting larger items). Making the Construction of each Game Item have a Development Time or require Extended Actions can modulate how often new items can occur. Besides allowing the Crafting to begin with, the use of Skills or particular Tools can also be used to influence the quality of the produced Game Items, the use of Resources, and the time taken to finish the action.
Any type of Game Items can be the result of Crafting, but Tools is worth mentioning as a subcategory since it may be required for players to engage in other types of Crafting and thereby can set up development chains where the New Abilities gained can be seen as a form of Character Development. For some types of Game Items, e.g. Ammunition, it can be worth considering that each completed Crafting action provides not one but several instances of the Game Items. When Crafting is instead used to modify existing Game Items this is most often to either counter Deterioration or give New or Improved Abilities - Upgrades and Sidegrades are specific examples of the latter.
The actions making Crafting possible can be Extra-Game Actions if they only can take place before gameplay begins.
Diegetic Aspects
Crafting allows players to help create the content in Game Worlds and is therefore a Diegetic Pattern.
Interface Aspects
Since Crafting typically concerns manipulating and transforming Game Items that one has, the interface for Crafting is quite often part of the interface for Inventories.
Consequences
Crafting provides a way for players or other Agents to engage in the Construction of Game Items in Game Worlds, quite likely resulting in Player Created Game Elements. Performing Crafting activities can be seen as making Investments since Resources are usually consumed while engaging in Crafting (if nothing else, gameplay time is consumed). Crafting makes those that engage in it into Converters, and when Tools or crafted Game Items are required to engage in other types of Crafting, this sets up Production-Consumption Chains. When this is kept to one Focus Loci, this provides a form of Character Development. In games with Persistent Game Worlds of Multiplayer Games, both this type of Crafting and repetitious "basic" Crafting can disrupt both the economy within the game and the Player Balance if not the effort to create Game Items is balanced with the value of them.
When Creative Control is given to players regarding Crafting, as for example in Minecraft or Slaves to Armok II: Dwarf Fortress, this gives them Framed Freedom and Constructive Gameplay. The knowledge of what Game Items can be construct, and what is required to do this, can be Strategic Knowledge. The possibility of Agents to create artifacts can be a vital component in explaining civilizations in Game Worlds, and therefore help instantiate Thematic Consistency (although of course only artifacts which are consistent with the theme should be possible to create).
Being an activity that does not inherently need to have risks involved or require player skills, Crafting can easily open up for Grinding. However, it can give some worth to other forms of Grinding, e.g. that of Collecting resources.
Relations
Can Instantiate
Construction, Constructive Gameplay, Converters, Extra-Game Actions, Improved Abilities, Investments, New Abilities, Player Created Game Elements, Thematic Consistency, Grinding, Privileged Abilities, Strategic Knowledge
with Creative Control
with Tools
Character Development, Production-Consumption Chains
Can Modulate
Collecting, Deterioration, Game Items, Game Worlds, Grinding, Persistent Game Worlds
Can Be Instantiated By
Privileged Abilities, Skills, Tools
Can Be Modulated By
Creative Control, Development Time, Extended Actions, Neighbors, Resources, Sidegrades, Skills, Tools, Upgrades
Possible Closure Effects
-
Potentially Conflicting With
Player Balance in games with Persistent Game Worlds in Multiplayer Games
History
New pattern created in this wiki.
References
-
Acknowledgements
-
